Global Sensitivity Analysis

Global Sensitivity Analysis

Global Sensitivity Analysis (GSA) methods are used to quantify the uncertainty in output of a model w.r.t. the parameters, their individual contributions, or the contribution of their interactions. The type of GSA method to use depends on the interest of the user, below we describe the methods available in the suite at the moment (some more are already in development) and explain what is the output of each of the methods and what it represents.

Installation

This functionality does not come standard with DifferentialEquations.jl. To use this functionality, you must install DiffEqSensitivty.jl:

]add DiffEqSensitivity
using DiffEqSensitivty

Morris Method

The Morris method also known as Morris’s OAT method where OAT stands for One At a Time can be described in the following steps:

We calculate local sensitivity measures known as “elementary effects”, which are calculated by measuring the perturbation in the output of the model on changing one parameter.

$EE_i = \frac{f(x_1,x_2,..x_i+ \Delta,..x_k) - y}{\Delta}$

These are evaluated at various points in the input chosen such that a wide “spread” of the parameter space is explored and considered in the analysis, to provide an approximate global importance measure. The mean and variance of these elementary effects is computed. A high value of the mean implies that a parameter is important, a high variance implies that its effects are non-linear or the result of interactions with other inputs. This method does not evaluate separately the contribution from the interaction and the contribution of the parameters individually and gives the effects for each parameter which takes into cpnsideration all the interactions and its individual contribution.

morris_effects = morris_sensitivity(f,param_range,param_steps;relative_scale=false,kwargs...)

morris_effects = morris_sensitivity(prob::DiffEqBase.DEProblem,alg,t,param_range,param_steps;kwargs...)

Here, f is just the model (as a julia function f(input_vector) -> output_vector or a DEProblem) you want to run the analysis on, param_range requires an array of 2-tuples with the lower bound and the upper bound, param_steps decides the value of $\Delta$ in the equation above and relative_scale, the above equation takes the assumption that the parameters lie in the range [0,1] but as this is not always the case scaling is used to get more informative, scaled effects.

Sobol Method

Sobol is a variance-based method and it decomposes the variance of the output of the model or system into fractions which can be attributed to inputs or sets of inputs. This helps to get not just the individual parameter's sensitivities but also gives a way to quantify the affect and sensitivity from the interaction between the parameters.

$Y = f_0+ \sum_{i=1}^d f_i(X_i)+ \sum_{i < j}^d f_{ij}(X_i,X_j) ... + f_{1,2...d}(X_1,X_2,..X_d)$
$Var(Y) = \sum_{i=1}^d V_i + \sum_{i < j}^d V_{ij} + ... + V_{1,2...,d}$

The Sobol Indices are "order"ed, the first order indices given by $S_i = \frac{V_i}{Var(Y)}$ the contribution to the output variance of the main effect of $X_i$, therefore it measures the effect of varying $X_i$ alone, but averaged over variations in other input parameters. It is standardised by the total variance to provide a fractional contribution. Higher-order interaction indices $S_{i,j}, S_{i,j,k}$ and so on can be formed by dividing other terms in the variance decomposition by $Var(Y)$.

sobol_second_order = sobol_sensitivity(f,param_range,N,order=2)

sobol_second_order = sobol_sensitivity(prob::DiffEqBase.DEProblem,alg,t,param_range,N,order=2)

Here f and param_range are the same as Morris's, providing a uniform interface.

Regression Method

If a sample of inputs and outputs $(X^n, Y^n) = 􏰀(X^{i}_1, . . . , X^{i}_d, Y_i)_{i=1..n}$􏰁 is available, it is possible to fit a linear model explaining the behavior of Y given the values of X, provided that the sample size n is sufficiently large (at least n > d).

The measures provided for this analysis by us in DiffEqSensitivity.jl are

a) Pearson Correlation Coefficient:

$r = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n} (x_i - \overline{x})(y_i - \overline{y})}{\sqrt{\sum_{i=1}^{n} (x_i - \overline{x})^2(y_i - \overline{y})^2}}$

b) Standard Regression Coefficient (SRC):

$SRC_j = \beta_{j} \sqrt{\frac{Var(X_j)}{Var(Y)}}$

where $\beta_j$ is the linear regression coefficient associated to $X_j$.

c) Partial Correlation Coefficient (PCC):

$PCC_j = \rho(X_j - \hat{X_{-j}},Y_j - \hat{Y_{-j}})$

where $\hat{X_{-j}}$􏰈 is the prediction of the linear model, expressing $X_{j}$ with respect to the other inputs and $\hat{Y􏰈_{-j}}$ is the prediction of the linear model where $X_j$ is absent. PCC measures the sensitivity of $Y$ to $X_j$ when the effects of the other inputs have been canceled.

regre_sensitivity = regression_sensitivity(f,param_range,param_fixed,n;coeffs=:rank)

regre_sensitivity = regression_sensitivity(prob::DiffEqBase.DEProblem,alg,t,param_range,param_fixed,n;coeffs=:rank)

Again, f and param_range are the same as above. An array of the true parameter values that lie within the param_range bounds are passed through the param_fixed argument. n determines the number of simulations of the model run to generate the data points of the solution and parameter values and the coeffs kwarg lets you decide the coefficients you want.

GSA example

Let's create the ODE problem to run our GSA on.

function f(du,u,p,t)
du[1] = p[1]*u[1] - p[2]*u[1]*u[2]
du[2] = -3*u[2] + u[1]*u[2]
end
u0 = [1.0;1.0]
tspan = (0.0,10.0)
p = [1.5,1.0]
prob = ODEProblem(f,u0,tspan,p)
t = collect(range(0, stop=10, length=200))

For Morris Method

m = DiffEqSensitivity.morris_sensitivity(prob,Tsit5(),t,[[1,5],[0.5,5]],[10,10],len_trajectory=1500,total_num_trajectory=1000,num_trajectory=150)

Let's get the means and variances from the MorrisSensitivity struct.

m.means

Out[9]: 2-element Array{Array{Float64,2},1}:
[0.0 0.0513678 … 7.91336 7.93783; 0.0 0.00115769 … 3.66156 3.67284]
[0.0 0.0488899 … 2.50728 2.359; 0.0 0.00112006 … 2.23431 2.44946]

m.variances

Out[10]: 2-element Array{Array{Float64,2},1}:
[0.0 1.94672e-5 … 26.4223 24.8513; 0.0 4.81347e-9 … 37.4061 30.3068]
[0.0 1.77615e-5 … 17.9555 14.9231; 0.0 4.47931e-9 … 48.074 51.9312]

This gives the means of the effects and it's variances over the entire timespan and thus we get 200-length arrays for each paramter and dependent variable pair.

We can plot the trajectory of the sensitivity with the standard deviation bars.

# For the first parameter (a)
stdv1 = sqrt.(m.variances[1])
p = plot(m.means[1]', yerror=stdv1)

# For the second parameter (b)
stdv2 = sqrt.(m.variances[2])
p = plot(m.means[2]', yerror=stdv2)

For Sobol Method


s0 = sobol_sensitivity(prob,Tsit5(),t,[[1,5],[0.5,5]],N,0)
Out[8]: 2-element Array{Array{Float64,2},1}:
[NaN 0.507831 … 1.00731 1.00436; NaN 1.92336 … 0.732384 0.730945]
[NaN 0.47214 … 0.676224 0.681525; NaN -1.68656 … 0.879557 0.877603]

s1 = sobol_sensitivity(prob,Tsit5(),t,[[1,5],[0.5,5]],N,1)
Out[9]: 2-element Array{Array{Float64,2},1}:
[NaN 0.39537 … 0.341697 0.343645; NaN -2.06101 … 0.10922 0.106976]
[NaN 0.652815 … 0.00910675 0.00815206; NaN 5.24832 … 0.296978 0.296639]

s2 = sobol_sensitivity(prob,Tsit5(),t,[[1,5],[0.5,5]],N,2)
Out[10]: 1-element Array{Array{Float64,2},1}:
[NaN -0.0596478 … 0.652303 0.657847; NaN -1.84504 … 0.645139 0.620036]

We can decide which order of Sobol Indices we are interested in my passing an argument for it, by default it gives the second order indices. Again the result is obtained over the entire timespan

We plot the first order and total order Sobol Indices for some timepoints for each of the parameters (a and b).


p1 = bar(["a","b"],[s0[1][end-2],s0[2][end-2]],color=[:red,:blue],title="Total Order Indices at t=9.949748743718592",legend=false)
p2 = bar(["a","b"],[s1[1][end-2],s1[2][end-2]],color=[:red,:blue],title="First Order Indices at t=9.949748743718592",legend=false)
p3 = bar(["a","b"],[s0[1][3],s0[2][3]],color=[:red,:blue],title="Total Order Indices at t=0.05025125628140704",legend=false)
p4 = bar(["a","b"],[s1[1][3],s1[2][3]],color=[:red,:blue],title="First Order Indices at t=0.05025125628140704",legend=false)
plo = plot(p1,p2,p3,p4,layout=(4,1),size=(600,500))


Here we plot the Sobol indices of first order and the total Sobol indices for the parameters a and b. The plots are obtained by getting the Sobol Indices at the t = 9.949748743718592 and the t = 0.05025125628140704 time point of the first dependent variable x(t) from the 200-length sensitivities over the entire time span. The length of the bar represents the quantification of the sensitivity of the output to that parameter and hence for the 199th time point you can say that x(t) is more sensitive to b, also you can observe how the relative difference between a and b is larger in the first order than the total order indices, this tells us that most of the contribution of a to x(t) arises from interactions and it's individual non-interaction contribution is significantly lesser than b and vice-versa for b as it's first order plot indicates quite high value.